Plymouth Township, September 30, 2025
News Summary
Plymouth Township residents successfully opposed a proposed harness racing and gambling track by Northville Downs, with a federal judge ruling in favor of the township. The lawsuit sought $10 million after zoning requests were denied, but the court emphasized the township acted lawfully. Concerns included noise pollution and traffic, leading to proactive community engagement and changes in township leadership. This ruling reinforces Plymouth’s commitment to community welfare amidst development pressures.
Plymouth Township residents successfully opposed the establishment of a harness racing and gambling track proposed by Northville Downs, as a federal judge dismissed a $10 million lawsuit filed against the township. U.S. District Court Judge Brandy McMillion ruled that Plymouth Township acted lawfully when it denied the zoning request for the harness racing facility due to the absence of finalized zoning approval.
In recent years, the community expressed significant concerns regarding the potential impacts of the Northville Downs project, including anticipated noise pollution, increased traffic, and the facility’s proximity to schools and local businesses. Local activism driven by these concerns resulted in a change in township leadership, with a new supervisor taking office who was more cautious about the proposed development project.
Negotiations between the Plymouth Township Board and Northville Downs reached an impasse in spring 2024 concerning a Community Benefits Agreement, which aims to mitigate the effects of developments on local communities. As a result of this stalemate, the township denied Northville Downs’ zoning request, leading the organization to file a lawsuit, claiming that the township violated a development contract.
The court’s decision reiterated that Northville Downs may have acted prematurely by purchasing a $10 million parcel of land without securing necessary approvals. Judge McMillion emphasized that the township had the right to deny the project due to the lack of finalized zoning. Following a resolution in January 2024 to terminate negotiations over the Community Benefits Agreement, Northville Downs took legal action against the township.
The court’s ruling dismissed Northville Downs’ federal claims “with prejudice,” which prohibits them from being refiled. However, it leaves some related state-level claims available for pursuit in state court. Plymouth Township officials asserted that their approach to zoning and the negotiation process was lawful and adhered to the necessary requirements, countering claims made by Northville Downs that the township made illegal demands.
Following the ruling, Plymouth Township Supervisor Chuck Curmi expressed relief, stating that the lawsuit served as a distraction and that the project itself was ill-conceived. Former Supervisor Kurt Heise felt vindicated by the court’s decision, reinforcing that the township officials had acted in good faith throughout the negotiations.
Plymouth Township maintained proper procedures and was not concerned about the legal fees due to effective bonding and insurance coverage. In contrast, Green Charter Township faced financial distress as a result of their negotiations with Gotion, which illustrates a governance failure when comparing the two townships.
The court’s ruling appears to further affirm Plymouth Township’s commitment to community well-being and responsible governance amidst development pressures.
FAQ
What was the Northville Downs proposal?
The Northville Downs proposal was for a harness racing and gambling track in Plymouth Township.
What concerns did Plymouth Township residents have?
Residents were concerned about noise, increased traffic, and the proximity of the facility to schools and businesses.
What actions did residents take against the proposed project?
Residents conducted research, publicized potential impacts, and attended town hall meetings to influence officials.
What resulted from the community activism?
Community activism led to the replacement of the township supervisor with one who was cautious towards the Downs development.
What led to the lawsuit by Northville Downs against Plymouth Township?
Northville Downs filed a $10 million lawsuit after the township denied their zoning request following stalled negotiations over a Community Benefits Agreement.
What was the judge’s ruling regarding the lawsuit?
The judge ruled in favor of Plymouth Township, stating they acted within their rights to deny the project and criticized Northville Downs for acting prematurely.
What were the implications of the court’s ruling for Northville Downs’ claims?
The court dismissed Northville Downs’ federal claims “with prejudice,” meaning they cannot be refiled, while leaving some state-level claims open for pursuit.
How did Plymouth Township officials react to the ruling?
Plymouth Township Supervisor Chuck Curmi expressed relief and stressed that the project was ill-conceived. Former Supervisor Kurt Heise felt vindicated.
What does this situation illustrate about other townships?
Plymouth Township’s success contrasts with Green Charter Township’s financial distress over negotiations, highlighting better governance practices.
Key Features of the Case
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Proposed Development | Northern Downs Harness Racing and Gambling Track |
| Community Concerns | Noise, traffic, proximity to schools, and businesses |
| Legal Actions | Northville Downs filed a $10 million lawsuit against the township |
| Court Ruling | The court ruled in favor of Plymouth Township, dismissing federal claims “with prejudice” |
| Impact of Ruling | Affirmed lawful township denial of zoning request |
| Neglected Community Benefits Agreement | Negotiations terminated due to an impasse in demands |
| Related Issues | Contrast with Green Charter Township’s financial struggles |
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Tragic Mass Shooting at Grand Blanc Township Church
Graye’s Greenhouse Undergoes Major Renovation and Community Expansion
Community Rebuilds Infrastructure After Tragic Fire Incident
Critical Injuries Reported in Elmira Township Collision
Michigan Faces Possible Government Shutdown as Budget Discussions Continue
New Baltimore Welcomes Sheetz Gas Station and Convenience Store
Sheetz Opens New Store in New Baltimore, Michigan
New Morning School to Permanently Close Due to Low Enrollment
MDOT Launches Construction Projects Ahead of Winter in Michigan
Fatal Crash in Ann Arbor Township Involves Semi-Truck
Additional Resources
- Hometown Life: Judge Sides With Plymouth Township
- Click On Detroit: Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Over Failed Northville Downs Relocation
- Detroit News: Federal Judge Dismisses Plymouth Twp Lawsuit
- Patch: Judge Tosses Plymouth Twp Lawsuit Over Failed Horse Track Talks
- Crain’s Detroit: Northville Downs Loses Lawsuit Against Plymouth Township
- Wikipedia: Plymouth Township, Michigan
Author: STAFF HERE PLYMOUTH WRITER
The PLYMOUTH STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREPlymouth.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Plymouth, Wayne County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the Plymouth Ice Festival, Art in the Park, and the Plymouth Fall Festival. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Plymouth Community Chamber of Commerce and Main Street Plymouth, plus leading businesses in automotive and retail that power the local economy such as Roush Industries and Downtown Plymouth businesses. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREDetroitMI.com, HEREGrandRapids.com, HERENorthville.com, and HERENovi.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Michigan's dynamic landscape.
